Better Family Photos

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, 11 October 2013

Recovering from Underexposure - A New Approach

Posted on 21:35 by Unknown

In my last post, I discussed my strategy for exposure for digital cameras, which usually results in images that are underexposed when downloaded straight-out-of-the-camera (SOOC).  In this post, I would like to discuss my current strategy for recovering shadows.  Here I use Lightroom but the same techniques can be used in other post-processing software.




COMPARISON OF THREE APPROACHES

Here is the SOOC version of the image above.


I used the approach I discussed in my last post, relying on ADL to expose for the highlights.  As expected, the SOOC is underexposed.  However, the relevant highlights are preserved:

even the candle highlights are preserved


The highlights in the window on camera right are not preserved but that's ok.  They don't add to the image (it was an overcast day with gray skies) and exposing for them would have led to more noise without much offsetting benefit.

Easy approach

The  easiest approach is of course to use the shadow slider (increase it as needed) and the highlight recovery slider (decrease as needed).  In my opinion it is also the least satisfying way to recover underexposure.  The result looks HDR-ish (but if you like that effect, then this is perfect for you -- boost the clarity slider next to make it look more like HDR).  Moreover, in some sensors like that of the D7100, using the shadow slider is more likely to reveal noise or worse, banding.
Using the shadow slider: HDR much?

Global approach
The next approach is one that I've posted about before.  In brief, instead of relying on the shadow slider, I use the exposure slider.  I do use the shadow slider as well, but only up to about +20 or sometimes +30.  More than that and it looks too artificial for me.  I use as little of the shadow slider as possible.

A +20 or +30 shadow adjustment for a scene that's exposed for highlights will nowhere be enough.  Therefore the heavy lifting ( sorry :) ) is done with the exposure slider which I use as much as necessary.  Using the exposure slider will be more likely to blow the highlights that are actually captured.  To offset that, I use aggressive highlight recovery.  As much as -200 (by using an adjustment brush on top of the highlight adjustment).  Unlike using the shadow recovery slider I don't find any issues with the highlight recovery.

For very contrasty scenes I get a little help by changing the camera calibration to a low contrast picture style and if necessary, by decreasing the contrast as well.

When the midtones look normal, I then work on restoring the oomph because the image will otherwise look very flat / low contrast.  To do that, I increase the white slider (making whites appear more white), and I decrease the shadow slider (deepening the blacks).  Does that effectively negate what I did with the highlight recovery and shadow recovery?  Not at all.  The net effect of those changes is to move the shadows and highlights a little closer to the middle, where it is easier to see them (partly because our eyes can differentiate more midtone shades).

Here is the result:


Here again is the first method for comparison:

This second method produces a more natural and more three-dimensional appearance.  Now let's talk about the third approach.

INTRODUCING THE HOBBY APPROACH

I call my current approach the Hobby approach for two reasons: first, it is styled after Strobist David Hobby's logic of using lights; second, because it is customized for each image, it is probably not usable for event pros who need to edit thousands of shots.  So, it's just for us hobbyists. :)  Well, ok, editorial and portrait shooters too.

Until about a year ago, I was a huge strobist fan.  My lighting collection attests to that (someday I'll review more of my lighting gear).  I'm still a fan, but after having gotten the D600 with its exceptional shadow recovery abilities, I found that I could get results with postprocessing that closely mimic real artificial lighting (lol).  Here's how it works (strobists among you will recognize the logic):

Shadow detail legibility
The first thing I do with the underexposed image is to raise the exposure for shadow legibility.  In strobist-speak that means increasing the exposure to the point where the details of relevant shadows can be seen.  What that exactly means varies depending on your shot and your taste.  If for example you want an intense-looking dramatic scene then the shadow details would be barely visible.  If you want a look that mimics Mr. Hobby's shooting style, you want shadow details that are pretty easy to see (enough that if you print the shot on newsprint with a lousy printer, you will still have enough detail).  I myself prefer something in between.

Here again is the SOOC shot:

And here is the shot with the exposure raised to my desired shadow legibility (in this case +0.36):

Highlights
To tame the highlights, I use the highlight recovery slider, that's all.  I don't mind being aggressive with it, although I watch to make sure the image doesn't become too flat.  For stubborn highlights, I use an adjustment brush or radial gradient to bring them down further.

Midtones
To raise the midtones, I use Lightroom 5's radial gradient.  To me it looks more convincing than using the adjustment brush.  If you're new to LR5, pls. note that the radial gradient can be changed to an oval/ellipse and can be tilted.

I use an inverse mask which means the effect will be within the circle that you apply instead of outside it.  I also increase the feathering from 50 to 75.  This simulates real world lights more closely (unless you want it to look like you used a snoot, in which case you decrease the feathering).  For each gradient I try not to increase more than +0.7 or else the result looks too obvious.

I apply this radial gradient everywhere I want to raise the midtones, starting from the darkest midtones.  For some areas, I apply overlapping radial gradients that are progressively smaller.  For example if I have a portrait shot from the waist up then I'll apply a radial gradient for the head and body, then to highlight the face, I'll add another radial gradient just to the head area.  Note that I don't just use one huge radial gradient to cover the arms as well -- I apply a separate radial gradient to each arm.

From the previous shadow legibility step:

Here are the areas where I applied a radial gradient (see the dots):

Result with midtone recovery:


Contrast
As with the second approach, I add punch to the image using the white slider, black slider, and sometimes the clarity slider.

That's pretty much all there is to this approach.  Note that this method cannot recreate rim lights or kickers or hard lights.  For those I use ambient light sources or flash.

Here are some more samples:








Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Olympus E-PL3 with 14-42 Lens $199; Moving from Nikon to MFT?
    I saw on 43rumors.com that the Olympus E-PL3 was being sold at Newegg for just $199 with the 14-42 kit lens included.  I checked it out and...
  • Exploring 3D Photography with the Loreo 3D Lens in a Cap
    When I hear of 3D photos or videos, my first impression is that it's gimmicky.  Interesting for one or two shots maybe and then after th...
  • Double Camera Strap & BlackRapid RS-5 Review
    This is a review of two camera straps: - The first is a double camera strap that's -- let's be blunt -- a knockoff of the BlackRapid...
  • 2x Lowepro Review: Toploader Zoom 45 AW & 55 AW + Unraveling The SlipLock™ Mystery
    Left: Lowepro Toploader Zoom 55AW, Right: 45AW, Middle: Canon 60D + 15-85 Welcome to a new rare photography accessory review as I'd lik...
  • Toys for the Big Kids: Speedlight Softbox
    In this post, we will have a look at a softbox for speedlights.  This post is part of a series that will cover equipment reviews for committ...
  • Sigma USB dock available for preorder
    B&H is offering the Sigma USB dock for preorder for $59 + s/h , due for shipping on May 18. The dock allows you to update your firmwar...
  • A Couple Of Yashica Oldies
    Yashica Electro 35 GTN + Yashica ST-7   How many of you know the above camera? Have you seen such a tripod before? Hit the jump for a flas...
  • Macro Talk: Canon EF-S 60mm f/2.8 Macro USM
    What is a macro lens? What if my zoom lens has a "Macro" designation, are they the same? Today I am going to chat a little about m...
  • Canon Professional Network
    I didn't know about Canon Professional Network until Syl Arena recently blogged about his 4-part article on speedlites.  I took a look ...
  • Minimizing Nikon D5200 and D7100 banding; Mysteries Remain
    Many people have noted that the Nikon D5200 and Nikon D7100 have banding in the shadows when the exposure is pushed.  In this post I'll ...

Categories

  • "alien bee"
  • "april fool's"
  • "ring flash"
  • "yong nuo"
  • 1"
  • 1/1.7"
  • 10-17
  • 10-20
  • 11-16
  • 15-85mm
  • 15z
  • 17-50 vc
  • 190cx pro3
  • 2.8
  • 2.8G
  • 2/3"
  • 200 f2.8
  • 200 L
  • 200mm
  • 200mm f/2.8
  • 200mm f/2.8 L II
  • 200mm f2.8
  • 200mm f28
  • 200mm f28 L II
  • 2012
  • 2013
  • 23 Samsung led
  • 24-105 f4
  • 24-70
  • 25 1.4
  • 28-105
  • 28-70
  • 35mm
  • 35mm f/2
  • 35mm f2
  • 360
  • 3rd party
  • 4.1
  • 4/3
  • 40 pancake
  • 40 panckae
  • 40 stm
  • 40-150R
  • 40mm f/2.8
  • 430EX
  • 43rumors
  • 45 18
  • 45 AW
  • 4x4
  • 50 14
  • 50 f14
  • 50-150
  • 50mm
  • 50mm f/1.4
  • 55 AW
  • 55-250
  • 550D
  • 55aw
  • 560ex
  • 580 ex ii
  • 580EX
  • 580EX II
  • 5d
  • 5d mark 2
  • 5d mark 3
  • 5D Mark II
  • 5d mark iii
  • 5d2
  • 600d
  • 600ex-rt
  • 60d
  • 60fps
  • 60mm macro
  • 650d
  • 6d
  • 7.5mm
  • 720p
  • 75 f1.8
  • 85mm f1.8
  • 8x12
  • abbc
  • abstract
  • accuracy
  • active d-lighting
  • adjustment
  • adl
  • AF
  • af point
  • AF Point Expansion
  • aftermarket
  • airport
  • alexandria
  • alien bee
  • alien bees
  • alienbee
  • alienbees
  • alternative
  • ambient
  • ambient light
  • angle
  • aperture priority
  • APS-C
  • apsc
  • assignment
  • auto focus
  • auto white balance
  • autofocus
  • AWB
  • awl
  • back button focus
  • background
  • background blur
  • backlight
  • backlighting
  • backlit
  • bad behavior
  • bad photography
  • balance
  • bare flash
  • battery
  • BBF
  • beach
  • beams
  • beauty dish
  • bellagio
  • BFT
  • birthday
  • black
  • black foamie thing
  • black rapid
  • blackrapid
  • blogs
  • blower
  • blown
  • blur
  • bokeh
  • bounce
  • bounce card
  • bounce flash
  • bower
  • bracket
  • brightness
  • brilliance
  • brolly grip
  • brother
  • build
  • burst mode
  • butterflies
  • butterfly
  • C.Fn
  • cable
  • cake
  • camera
  • camera bag
  • camera releases
  • camera settings
  • candle
  • candlelight
  • canon
  • Canon 100mm Macro L IS
  • canon 200mm f28L
  • canon 24-105
  • canon 40 stm
  • canon 40mm f28 pancake
  • canon 50
  • canon 50 1.4
  • canon 55-250
  • canon 5d mark 2
  • canon 5d mark ii
  • canon 5d mark iii
  • canon 5d2
  • canon 5d3
  • Canon 60d
  • canon 6d
  • canon g11
  • canon speedlite
  • car
  • carbon fiber
  • catch lights
  • cheap
  • christmas
  • clean
  • cleaning
  • clipped
  • clipping
  • close up
  • clouds
  • cls
  • clustered
  • color
  • compact
  • comparison
  • composition
  • compositional aid
  • construction
  • contrast
  • cooler master
  • copyright
  • core i7
  • cowboy
  • cowboystudio
  • cpl
  • creepy
  • crop factor
  • crop sensor
  • cyber commander
  • cybersync
  • d-lux
  • d-lux5
  • d3
  • d300
  • D5100
  • D600
  • d70
  • d700
  • D7100
  • d90
  • dark background
  • david hobby
  • daylight
  • dell 24 inch
  • depth of field
  • desert
  • diamond
  • digital
  • directional
  • distance
  • diy
  • dlux
  • dlux5
  • dng
  • double
  • dslr
  • DSLR bag
  • dual
  • dust
  • dx
  • dynamic range
  • earthquake
  • ebay
  • ebay trigger
  • eclipse
  • editing
  • EF 40mm f/2.8
  • ef-s 60mm
  • einstein
  • Electro GN
  • engagement
  • environmental portrait
  • ep5
  • equipment
  • ETTL
  • ettr
  • europe
  • events
  • evf
  • ex600
  • existing light
  • expensive
  • exposing to the right
  • exposure
  • f/3.5
  • family
  • faq
  • fasten-r3
  • favorite
  • fayoum
  • Fayoum desert
  • fill
  • fill light
  • film
  • filter
  • finepix
  • fire
  • fireplace
  • first impressions
  • fish-eye
  • fisheye
  • fix
  • FL600R
  • flash
  • flash bounce
  • flash sync
  • flash trigger
  • flashmeter
  • flashright
  • focal length
  • focus
  • food
  • football
  • fotodiox
  • fountain
  • freexwire
  • fuji
  • fujifilm
  • Full Frame
  • fun
  • fx
  • galaxy s 3
  • galaxy s4
  • gecko
  • GeForce gtx570 OC
  • gel
  • geomag
  • ggs
  • ghost
  • gigabyte z77 ud3h
  • glass
  • gn
  • Goodbye
  • gorillapod
  • gregg
  • grid
  • grip
  • group shot
  • gskill ripjaws
  • guide
  • guide number
  • gx7
  • haf 912
  • handheld
  • hands on
  • hands-on
  • hdr
  • head shot
  • hiatus
  • high dynamic range
  • high iso
  • high speed sync
  • highlight
  • highlights
  • histogram
  • holder
  • holiday
  • home
  • home made
  • Honda civic
  • honeycomb
  • hotshoe
  • hoya
  • humor
  • i9500
  • id
  • image quality
  • impressions
  • indoor flash
  • infrared
  • infringement
  • insects
  • inverse square law
  • japan
  • jewel
  • jewelry
  • joby head
  • jpeg
  • Kingston hyperX SSD
  • kirk tuck
  • kl bird park
  • krakow
  • kuala lumpur
  • las vegas
  • lastolite
  • laurence kim
  • lax
  • lcd
  • leica
  • lens
  • lens cap
  • lens compression
  • lens review
  • lenses
  • lenspen
  • lensrentals
  • light
  • light painting
  • lighting
  • lightroom
  • lightroom 4
  • lightroom 5
  • location
  • long
  • long exposure
  • los angeles
  • low key
  • low light
  • Lowepro
  • Lowepro 45aw
  • Lowepro 55aw
  • lr4
  • lumiquest softbox III
  • lumix
  • lx-5
  • lx5
  • m4/3
  • m43
  • macro
  • macro adapter
  • makernotes
  • malaysia
  • manfrotto
  • manfrotto tripod
  • manual
  • mark ii
  • mark iii
  • MFT
  • mft. micro four thirds
  • micro four thirds
  • mielec
  • migration
  • mini review
  • mirror
  • mirror-less
  • mirrorless
  • mobile
  • modification
  • modifier
  • monobloc
  • monoblock
  • monolight
  • motion
  • motion blur
  • multi function printer
  • multiple
  • nano crystal
  • natural light
  • neil
  • Neil VN
  • niekerk
  • nikkor
  • nikon
  • nikon d600
  • noise
  • off camera
  • oil
  • olympus
  • olympus 12-50
  • Olympus 40-150
  • olympus 45
  • olympus 45 18
  • olympus om-d em-5
  • om-d
  • omd
  • omd em1
  • omd em5
  • omd em6
  • on-camera
  • one inch
  • overexposure
  • overpowering sun
  • panasonic
  • panasonic leica 25 14
  • pancake
  • party
  • passport
  • pastries
  • pastry
  • pc
  • pentax
  • peter
  • phone
  • phone photography
  • photo
  • photo tips
  • photography
  • photokina
  • photomerge
  • photoshop
  • photoshop elements
  • planning
  • pocketwizard
  • point and shoot
  • poland
  • polarizer
  • popup
  • popup flash
  • portrait
  • post processing
  • post-processing
  • postprocessing
  • product
  • product shots
  • profile
  • protection
  • protector
  • quad-flash
  • quantum
  • radiopopper
  • raid 0
  • Range finder
  • raw
  • raw editing
  • raw+jpeg
  • rays
  • real
  • recovery
  • reflection
  • reflector
  • resources
  • restaurant
  • review
  • rf-603
  • rf603
  • ricoh
  • ring
  • ringflash
  • robin wong
  • roger cicala
  • rogue
  • rokinon
  • roll off
  • roll-off
  • rolloff
  • rs-5
  • rs-7
  • rumors
  • s5
  • s5 pro
  • s5pro
  • samples
  • samsung
  • samyang
  • sb-26
  • sb-80
  • sb26
  • sb800
  • screen protector
  • sensor
  • sensor swab
  • sensorclear
  • sensorklean
  • sensorklear
  • separation
  • shadow
  • shadow pulling
  • shadows
  • shards
  • sharpening
  • sharpness
  • shoot through
  • shoot-through
  • shoot-thru
  • shooting technique
  • shootout
  • short
  • sigma
  • sigma 50-150
  • skin tones
  • skylight
  • Slik Mini Tripod
  • slingshot
  • slow
  • small
  • smooth
  • soft
  • softbox
  • sony
  • sony a99
  • sony rx100
  • sony t10
  • specular
  • speed
  • speedlight
  • speedlite
  • spinlight
  • spots
  • standard
  • stockholm
  • story
  • strap
  • strobe
  • strobist
  • studio
  • studio strobe
  • subject
  • substitute
  • sudden
  • summilux
  • sunrise
  • sunset
  • sweden
  • swivel
  • sync speed
  • t2i
  • t3i
  • Table top tripod
  • tamron
  • technique
  • techniques
  • tele
  • telephoto
  • thinktank retrospective 5
  • third party
  • tips
  • tokina
  • tonal
  • tonality
  • tone curve
  • toploader
  • toys
  • translucent
  • travel photography
  • tri-flash
  • Tribute
  • trifold
  • trigger
  • tripod
  • truth
  • ttl
  • TTL Cord
  • u43
  • ultra-wide
  • ultrawide
  • umbrella
  • underexposure
  • unlimited sync speed
  • up-rise
  • up-rise 15z
  • update
  • uprise
  • USM
  • uv
  • uwa
  • vanguard
  • versus
  • vertical
  • video
  • view nx2
  • visual science lab
  • vs
  • wadi rayan
  • wd caviar black
  • web
  • weekend
  • westin
  • white balance
  • white lightning
  • wide
  • wide angle
  • window
  • wireless
  • wireless flash
  • wireless release
  • wireless trigger
  • workflow
  • Yashica
  • yashica gtn
  • yashica st-7
  • yn-560
  • yn-560ex
  • yn-ex600
  • yn560
  • yong nuo
  • yongnuo
  • zack arias
  • zoom
  • zoom toploader
  • zuiko

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (165)
    • ►  December (5)
    • ►  November (10)
    • ▼  October (8)
      • Happy Halloween
      • Thoughts on Nikon DF and Sony A7
      • 2013: The Camera Year
      • Recovering from Underexposure - A New Approach
      • The Dead Gecko
      • Comments on the Nikon D610 and Pentax K-3
      • Post Processing Series: Episode 3
      • Exposure for Digital Cameras
    • ►  September (7)
    • ►  August (3)
    • ►  July (11)
    • ►  June (10)
    • ►  May (15)
    • ►  April (19)
    • ►  March (33)
    • ►  February (24)
    • ►  January (20)
  • ►  2012 (193)
    • ►  December (17)
    • ►  November (22)
    • ►  October (34)
    • ►  September (47)
    • ►  August (12)
    • ►  July (11)
    • ►  June (10)
    • ►  May (13)
    • ►  April (13)
    • ►  March (8)
    • ►  February (1)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ►  2011 (141)
    • ►  December (8)
    • ►  November (8)
    • ►  October (7)
    • ►  September (9)
    • ►  August (13)
    • ►  July (13)
    • ►  June (19)
    • ►  May (17)
    • ►  April (25)
    • ►  March (22)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile